Current:Home > StocksNPR and 'New York Times' ask judge to unseal documents in Fox defamation case-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
NPR and 'New York Times' ask judge to unseal documents in Fox defamation case
View Date:2024-12-24 07:31:12
Lawyers for NPR News and The New York Times have jointly filed a legal brief asking a judge to unseal hundreds of pages of documents from a $1.6 billion defamation lawsuit filed by an elections technology company against Fox News.
"This lawsuit is unquestionably a consequential defamation case that tests the scope of the First Amendment," the challenge brought by the news organizations reads. "It has been the subject of widespread public interest and media coverage and undeniably involves a matter of profound public interest: namely, how a broadcast network fact-checked and presented to the public the allegations that the 2020 Presidential election was stolen and that plaintiff was to blame."
Dominion Voting Systems has sued Fox and its parent company over claims made by Fox hosts and guests after the November 2020 presidential elections that the company had helped fraudulently throw the election to Joe Biden. Those claims were debunked — often in real time, and sometimes by Fox's own journalists. Dominion alleges that much potential business has been disrupted and that its staffers have faced death threats.
Fox argues it was vigorously reporting newsworthy allegations from inherently newsworthy people - then President Donald Trump and his campaign's attorneys and surrogates. Fox and its lawyers contend the case is an affront to First Amendment principles and that the lawsuit is intended to chill free speech. NPR has asked both sides for comment and will update this story as they reply.
The legal teams for Dominion and Fox filed rival motions before Delaware Superior Court Judge Eric M. Davis earlier this month: in Dominion's case to find that Fox had defamed the company ahead of the April trial, in Fox's to dismiss all or much of the claims.
Documents draw upon expansive searches of electronic messages and testimony from scores of witnesses
Those motions contained hundreds of pages of documents cataloguing the findings from the so-called "discovery" process. They will draw upon hours of testimony from scores of witnesses, including media magnate Rupert Murdoch as well as expansive searches of texts, emails, internal work messages and other communications and records from figures on both sides.
Previous revelations have offered narrow windows on the operations inside Fox after the election: a producer beseeching colleagues to keep host Jeanine Pirro from spouting groundless conspiracy theories on the air; primetime star Sean Hannity's claim under oath he did not believe the claims of fraud "for one second" despite amplifying such allegations on the air; Fox News Media CEO Suzanne Scott's pleas "not to give the crazies an inch." The motions sought by the two news organizations would yield far more information.
In the joint filing, NPR and The New York Times note they do not know the contents of the materials and therefore do not know whether there are instances in which public disclosure could do either side harm. They therefore ask Judge Davis "to ensure the parties meet their high burden to justify sealing information which goes to the heart of very public and significant events."
The documents will help the public determine "whether Defendants published false statements with actual malice and whether the lawsuit was filed to chill free speech," reads the filing by attorney Joseph C. Barsalona II, for the Times and NPR. "Accordingly, the interest in access to the Challenged Documents is vital."
Disclosure: This story was written by NPR media correspondent David Folkenflik and edited by Senior Business Editor Uri Berliner. Karl Baker contributed to this article. Under NPR's protocol for reporting on matters involving the network, no corporate official or senior news executive read this story before it was posted.
veryGood! (2)
Related
- Skiing legend Lindsey Vonn ends retirement, plans to return to competition
- Nordstrom Jaw-Dropping 75% Off Spring Sale Has Deals on Levi's, Madewell, Vince Camuto & More
- Meghan Markle Scores Legal Victory in Sister Samantha's Defamation Case
- Pressure On The World's Biggest Polluters Is Increasing. But Can It Force Change?
- What’s the secret to growing strong, healthy nails?
- Blac Chyna Shares Her Kids King and Dream's Reactions to Her Breast and Butt Reduction Surgeries
- Man accused of killing girlfriend, cutting up and cooking her body in alleged bid to hide the evidence
- Elle Fanning Confirms Breakup With Max Minghella
- Richard Allen found guilty in the murders of two teens in Delphi, Indiana. What now?
- Why Josh Lucas Is Confident Yellowstone Can Survive Without Kevin Costner
Ranking
- Celtics' Jaylen Brown calls Bucks' Giannis Antetokounmpo a 'child' over fake handshake
- Emily Ratajkowski Hinted at New Romance Weeks Before Harry Styles Makeout Session
- This Glow-Enhancing Lotion With 15,300+ 5-Star Reviews Is a Primer, Highlighter, Moisturizer, and More
- Flood Deaths Are Rising In Germany, And Officials Blame Climate Change
- When do new 'Yellowstone' episodes come out? Here's the Season 5, Part 2 episode schedule
- Iran helping Russia build plant to manufacture drones for likely use in Ukraine, White House says
- Dwyane Wade Asks Daughter Zaya to Change His Phone Contact to This After Hall of Fame Honor
- Why Wildfire Is Not Just A Western Problem
Recommendation
-
Deion Sanders says he would prevent Shedeur Sanders from going to wrong team in NFL draft
-
Ecuadoran woman who knocked on coffin during her own wake has died
-
Greece migrant boat capsize leaves hundreds missing, with fear 100 kids trapped in hold
-
Iran helping Russia build plant to manufacture drones for likely use in Ukraine, White House says
-
Are Ciara Ready and Russell Wilson Ready For Another Baby? She Says…
-
Tom Brady's Latest Outing With His and Gisele Bündchen's Kids Is a Work of Art
-
Andy Cohen Teases Surprising Vanderpump Rules “Turns” Before the Reunion
-
India and Pakistan brace as very severe Cyclone Biparjoy bears down on their coasts